Claiming your business listing couldn't be easier! Just fill in the information below to begin making the most of your listing and we will contact you shortly to complete the process.





ex: (888) 543-3210

Ficarellas Pizzeria

21 Liberty
Batavia, NY 14020
(585) 343-5545
100.0
[1]
0.0
[0]
100.0
[3]
0.0
[0]
0.0
[0]
72.5
[4]

Reviews

(20724063)
6436
100
Dec 21, 2011
By: Matt
Ficarellas Pizzeria
21 Liberty
Batavia , NY 14020

I just ordered from this pizzeria today 12/21/11. Having just moved to Batavia from Buffalo I wanted to find a good Pizzeria and it seems there are many to choose from in this town. My search is over, I found my regular go to pizza joint. The pizza and wings were exceptional, I also tried a sub sandwich which they call a stinger - best sub I have ever had. I look forward to trying the different items on their extensive menu in the future.

Pros: Extensive menu

Cons: None

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (0) No (0)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
(20724063)
6344
100
Dec 07, 2011
By: dantex
Ficarellas Pizzeria
21 Liberty
Batavia , NY 14020

My bad, site works fine. I love pizza. Italy rules.

Pros: Pizza!

Cons: None, I love chicken wings

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (0) No (0)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
(20724063)
6342
80
Dec 07, 2011
By: dantex
Ficarellas Pizzeria
21 Liberty
Batavia , NY 14020

I dont understand, your website leads to nowhere, and its kinda sad, but i wanted some pizza, but all the links are broken, and its all misplaced, and its just an eyesore honestly, but i like your chicken wings.

Pros: Chicken Wings, and Pizza

Cons: Broken site, links lead nowhere, and its sad. :(

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (0) No (0)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
(20724063)
6316
10
Dec 03, 2011
Ficarellas Pizzeria
21 Liberty
Batavia , NY 14020

Bad experience and was shrugged off by owner as lying.

Cons: As a long time(10+yrs)loyal customer, I recently (12/2/11) encountered a problem with my sub. Either the cheese or mayo was staring to go bad and had a slight funky smell. Shortly after eating almost all the sub I started to suffer nausea and vomiting. The sub was the only thing I ate that day,so I know it was due to it being *bad*. I contacted the shop the next AM at opening and spoke with the manager who relayed my message to the owner when he dropped by. The owner refused to make any type of restitution for good customer relations because he's been 'scammed' a lot in the past. I am offended that I was not believed. In this economy (and being on a fixed income), spending $10 for a sandwich from there with no guarantee it will be fresh & edible is not right. Ordering from them is a crapshoot with no recourse. They have lost an avid customer for life and I plan to discourage friends and anyone I meet from giving them any business. It's really a sad way to run a business.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (2) No (1)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
(17606616)
5724
100
Oct 03, 2011
By: linda
Ficarella's Pizzeria
21 Liberty
Batavia , NY 14020

I love this place! The employees remember me every time I come in for an order and I can't find a better pizza in Batavia. I highly recommend Ficarella's!

Pros: Great service and excellent pizza.

Cons: Absolutely none.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (1) No (2)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
(17606616)
5633
100
Sep 20, 2011
By: Mike
Ficarella's Pizzeria
21 Liberty
Batavia , NY 14020

Love this place! GREAT food and friendly service! Love the drive up window too. Don't be fooled by the name "pizzeria" the menu is HUGE! Great food for great value. We're going back again and again for sure! Would recommend it for sure. And great coupons too!

Pros: Excellent pizza, very many varieties, many I had never heard of before. Fast service and friendly. Good prices. Many other dishes on menu if you don't want pizza, and we have had many other things and every time it's been excellent.

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (4) No (0)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
(17606616)
5414
100
Aug 25, 2011
By: Ar
Ficarella's Pizzeria
21 Liberty
Batavia , NY 14020

I've been a customer for years and can't say enough about Ficarella's. The prices are fair, the facility is clean and comfortable, the staff is friendly, and the food is always delicious and ready on time. I highly recommend Ficarella's!

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (5) No (0)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
(13441611)
563
100
Dec 17, 2009
By: Rob
Ficarellas Pizzeria
21 Liberty
Batavia , NY 14020

This is a GREAT place to eat. Only DRIVE-UP WINDOW pizzeria I have seen. Friendly service, very accomodating. The menu is quite extensive to be called a pizzeria. Many selections besides pizza & wings. Salads, wraps, subs, pasta dishes, seafood, salads...and many more. Menu items reasonable prices too. Great place to bring friends and family! We're going back for sure!

Pros: GREAT food, DRIVE UP WINDOW, friendly service, comfortable dining, prices are right.

Cons: can't think of any...really...

Did you find this review helpful? Yes (25) No (1)
Are you the owner of this business? Reply
Click to select your destination